Beginner’s Guide to Understanding Varnish Furniture Finish

When it comes to furniture refinishing, paints and stains tend to receive most of the attention. After all, sorting through stacks of fascinating color swatches and obsessing over undertones is far more interesting than picking out a clear coat. The truth is that varnish is like the unsung hero of woodworking and furniture refinishing—it enhances the beauty of your piece while providing essential protection against wear and tear.

But what exactly is varnish, and which one is right for your furniture makeover?

In this guide, we’ll answer that question by breaking down the different types of varnish, their chemical makeup, and how they compare in terms of durability, finish, and application. Whether you’re restoring an antique dresser, protecting an outdoor wood project, or adding a glossy sheen to your latest DIY creation, understanding the properties of varnish will help you choose the best option for long-lasting results. Let’s dive in!

But first, some legalese for your reading pleasure!

THIS POST CONTAINS AFFILIATE LINKS TO PRODUCTS. IF YOU PURCHASE PRODUCTS THROUGH THESE LINKS, THEN I MAY RECEIVE A SMALL COMMISSION AT NO COST TO YOU.
I ONLY RECOMMEND PRODUCTS THAT I USE AND/OR HAVE RESEARCHED AND WOULD USE.

Chemical Makeup of Varnish

While modern-day varnishes often include man-made chemical compounds, historic varnishes were a combination of natural ingredients. These ingredients were sometimes boiled to produce a faster drying, stronger finish, such as Danish Oil. Regardless, all varnishes are a combination of these ingredients:

Component	Purpose	Examples
Resins	Provide hardness and protection	Polyurethane, Alkyd, Acrylic, Rosin, Copal, Sandarac
Solvents	Thin varnish, control drying	Mineral spirits, Water, Ethanol, Turpentine
Oils	Improve flow and adhesion	Linseed oil, Tung oil, Soybean oil
Driers	Speed up curing	Cobalt, Zinc, or Manganese salts

Polyurethane is one of the most common types, known for its durability, scratch and water resistance, but you can also find varnishes made with alkyd or acrylic resins for different effects.

Polyurethane Varnish

Polyurethane is the go-to for high-traffic furniture and surfaces that need heavy-duty protection.

Best For: High-traffic areas such as floors, countertops, and furniture exposed to frequent use or moisture.

Composition: Polyurethane is a synthetic resin made from a combination of polyol (a type of alcohol) and an isocyanate. These two components undergo a chemical reaction that forms a strong, durable polymer. This polyurethane resin is then combined with alkyd resin to create brush-on polyurethane varnish.

Pros:

• Excellent protection against scratches, stains, and moisture. Perfect for surfaces that will face a lot of wear and tear!
• Available in either a glossy, satin, or matte finish.
• Available in both oil-based and water-based formulas, offering flexibility for different project needs.

Cons:

• The application process can be trickier, showing brush marks if not applied carefully.
• Oil-based versions tend to have strong fumes and longer drying times.
• Requires scuffing between coats to ensure adhesion and does not bond well to other finishes.
• Does not hold up well to sunlight.

Alkyd Varnish

Alkyd varnish is made from synthetic resins derived from oils (often soybean, linseed, or safflower oil) and fatty acids. This varnish offers a traditional glossy finish and good moisture resistance, often preferred for indoor furniture or decorative woodwork.

Best For: Furniture, cabinets, and doors needing a rich, polished look.

Composition: Alkyd varnish is made by chemically modifying oils and adding resins and solvents. This process results in a resin that is more durable and faster-drying than traditional oils.

Pros:

• Beautiful gloss
• Enhances grain
• Good water resistance

Cons:

• Tends to yellow over time
• Strong fumes
• Longer curing time

Acrylic Varnish

This water-based varnish is beginner-friendly, dries fast, and doesn’t yellow over time. It’s favored for its ease of use and eco-friendly nature, as it has fewer toxic fumes compared to its oil-based counterparts.

Best For: Light-colored wood, craft projects, or pieces that won’t see heavy wear.

Composition: Acrylic varnish is made from synthetic acrylic resins that are water-soluble. It’s usually thinned with water, and often, it’s mixed with other resins or stabilizers to improve performance.

Pros:

• Low odor and easy cleanup
• Fast drying
• Clear, non-yellowing finish

Cons:

• Less durable
• Can leave streaks
• Not ideal for high-traffic areas

Spirit Varnish

Shellac is a traditional varnish made from natural resins dissolved in alcohol. It creates a warm, high-gloss finish but requires more maintenance than modern alternatives.

Best For: Antique furniture, musical instruments, or restoration projects.

Composition: Shellac is formed when shellac, sandarac, or mastic resins are dissolved in denatured alcohol.

Pros:

• Fast drying
• Easy to repair or touch up
• Deep, rich finish

Cons:

• Not moisture or heat resistant
• Requires careful application

Spar Varnish

Originally developed for ship masts, spar varnish remains a top choice for outdoor wood protection due to its flexibility and UV resistance.

Best For: Outdoor furniture, fences, garden planters, and boats.

Composition: Originally formulated with drying oils (like tung or linseed) and resins, modern versions may include polyurethane for enhanced durability.

Pros:

• Withstands harsh weather
• UV and water resistant
• Expands and contracts with temperature changes

Cons:

• Long drying and curing times
• Not ideal for indoor furniture

Summary of Varnish Differences:

Property	Polyurethane	Alkyd	Acrylic	Spirit	Spar
Durability	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Excellent	⭐⭐⭐⭐ Good	⭐⭐ Moderate	⭐⭐ Moderate	⭐⭐⭐⭐ Excellent (outdoor)
Finish	Glossy, satin, matte	Rich, glossy	Clear, matte to gloss; non-yellowing	High-gloss, warm tone; deepens wood color	Glossy to semi-gloss; slight amber tone
Drying Time	4–6 hrs (touch), 24+ hrs (fully cured)	6–8 hrs (touch), 24–48 hrs (fully cured)	30 min–1 hr (touch), 24 hrs (fully cured)	15–30 min (touch), 1–2 hrs (recoat), 12–24 hrs (cure)	6–8 hrs (touch), 48–72 hrs (fully cured)
Best For	High-traffic surfaces: floors, tabletops, cabinets	Traditional furniture, interior trim, cabinetry	Crafts, artwork, light-use furniture	Fine antiques, musical instruments, historical restoration	Outdoor furniture, boats, doors, exterior trim
Environmental Impact	High VOCs (especially oil-based)	Moderate VOCs (oil-based)	Low VOCs, water-based	High VOCs due to alcohol base	High VOCs; newer water-based formulas available
Ease of Application	Moderate (brush/roller/spray), needs sanding between coats	Moderate (often brushed), may yellow	Easy (brush/spray), streaks possible	Requires skill for French polishing or brushing, thin coats	Tricky—requires careful layering to prevent drips and sags, multiple coats needed
Historical Use	Modern (20th century onward)	Early 20th century onward	Late 20th century to present	16th century onward; peak in 18th–19th century	Developed in 19th century for marine use; furniture use in 20th century

Final Thoughts:

Choosing the right varnish depends on your project’s needs: is it indoor or outdoor? Will the piece face heavy use or just light decorative wear? Do you need a quick-drying solution or the toughest protection possible?

Each type of varnish has its time to shine—and now that you know the differences, you’re ready to make the best choice for your next refinishing masterpiece.

• Polyurethane is the best choice for durability, especially in high-use areas, but it takes longer to dry and can have stronger fumes.
• Alkyd varnish offers a rich, glossy finish with good durability but may yellow over time, making it less ideal for light-colored woods.
• Acrylic varnish is perfect for quick projects, especially if you’re looking for a low-toxicity option with minimal yellowing, though it’s not as tough as polyurethane or alkyd.
• Spirit varnish is great for restoring antiques or applying delicate finishes on fine furniture and instruments, offering a beautiful, traditional look that’s easy to repair but not as water- or alcohol-resistant.
• Spar varnish is best for outdoor projects where flexibility and UV resistance matter most, like porch furniture, doors, and boats, though it can take longer to cure and isn’t ideal for indoor, high-traffic surfaces.

Top Pick	Polyurethane	Alkyd	Acrylic	Spirit	Spar
Brand	Varathane Ultimate Polyurethane (Oil-Based)	Sikkens Cetol Marine Varnish	General Finishes High Performance Topcoat	Zinsser Bulls Eye Shellac	Epifanes Clear Varnish
Why It’s the Best	Durable with superior protection against scratches, stains, and moisture. Available in multiple finishes.	Marine-grade durability, perfect for outdoor use and harsh environments. Resistant to UV and saltwater.	Durable and easy to apply, provides good protection while drying quickly. Ideal for furniture and cabinetry.	Time-tested finish that provides a rich, warm glow. Easy to repair and recoat. Perfect for historical pieces and antiques.	Industry gold standard for marine and exterior use. Exceptional UV protection, flexibility, and long-term durability.
Finish Options	Satin, semi-gloss, and gloss	Gloss	Dead flat, flat, satin, semi-gloss, and gloss	Clear amber (glossy)	Gloss, satin (with flattening agent)
Best For	High-traffic areas (floors, furniture)	Furniture, cabinetry, and moderate-traffic areas	Furniture and cabinetry	Fine antiques, musical instruments, traditional furniture restoration	Outdoor furniture, doors, boats, and other weather-exposed surfaces

And there you have it! Your ultimate guide to understanding varnish and picking the perfect one for your next furniture project! Whether you’re aiming for museum-worthy restoration or a durable dining table finish, knowing the ins and outs of each varnish type sets you up for success. From historic spirit varnishes to modern polyurethanes, you’ve now got the tools to protect your hard work and bring out the natural beauty of your piece.

Ready to put that knowledge to use? Grab your favorite finish, find the right paintbrush, roll up those sleeves, and let’s make something beautiful together! Don’t forget to bookmark this guide, share it with your DIY bestie, and check out our project tutorials for more hands-on help and inspiration!

Still unsure which varnish is right for your piece? Drop your project details in the comments or shoot me a message—I’d love to help!

---